top of page

THE RESTAURANT MONOLOGUES: The Making of an Institution

Writer: Carolyn Fromm Papetti
Carolyn Fromm Papetti
5 days ago
4 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

There is apparently no restaurant quite as beloved as one that has just announced its closing. In our nation's capital, PoPville has become something of a town crier for restaurant comings and goings. With each announcement, the communal reminiscing begins. Suddenly, everyone has a story about a place they haven't visited since the Clinton administration. Of course, the public outpouring of sentiment is real. A restaurant, which is really just four walls, somehow made you feel something. It was your third place for a period in your life. Memories were made within those walls, often with people who are no longer part of our lives, back when we were versions of ourselves we barely recognize. Perhaps we're mourning more than the restaurant itself.


I've often wondered about this, particularly when I think about my years at East Hampton's iconic Nick & Toni's restaurant. First and foremost, it was a celebrity haunt, hardly a place where locals could simply walk in and expect a table. Yet it had become part of the community's identity, even if it was more accessible to city folks than to the locals themselves. Like most cities, Washington has its share of beloved institutions as well. Ben's Chili Bowl and Filomena come to mind. Their identities have become intertwined with the city's own, but is it longevity alone that makes them special?


When we opened our restaurant in 2018, we wanted to create a sense of belonging in the neighborhood where we live and raise our children. We had a simple truth that would guide us: We create a sense of community. Over time, we've watched neighbors run into neighbors while dining with us, authors celebrate with receptions after their book talks at Politics & Prose and families return to commemorate occasions that mark their lives. Children who grew up in our dining room are now young adults, choosing us for their first Thanksgiving week meal home from college. It's touching knowing that, among all the things they've missed while away, our little restaurant is one of the places they look forward to coming home to.


Perhaps the distinction between a restaurant and an institution isn't how long it's been around, but how deeply it's become woven into the lives of the people around it. And I recognize that becoming an institution and remaining one are two entirely different accomplishments.


As restaurateurs, we've learned that the onus is upon us to remain relevant. We can rest on the reputation we earned when we opened, three chefs ago. Or we can keep coming up with new ideas, finding ways to connect with people, and giving them reasons to return. And that requires tenacity and grit. Some days I have an abundance of both. Other days, throwing in the bar rag holds an irresistible appeal.


Restaurant ownership requires a certain degree of selective amnesia. Otherwise, I'm not sure any of us would keep doing it. Some episodes, however, are harder to forget than others. One particular Thursday in August 2024 comes to mind. Our chef of many years quit without warning or notice. It had been a relatively uneventful evening by restaurant standards. All the equipment was running at full throttle and everyone had shown up for work. There hadn't been any discernibly difficult customers that night either. Earlier that week, we'd had a rather heated fall menu meeting during which he insisted he was taking the garlic bread off the American side of our menu. I insisted he was not. We hadn't spoken about it since.


That evening, he said good night and fist-bumped Massimo. At 11 p.m., we received a text saying he had quit, effective immediately. Then he blocked us. My first thought was, Is this about the garlic bread?


Massimo and I didn't sleep that night. The next day was Friday. We needed to be open for the weekend. I mean, didn't we? People expected us to be open. What would it look like if they walked up and we were closed? How would we meet payroll without those crucial weekend sales? What would we tell our employees?


So we showed up, not knowing what to expect or even if we could actually open. We awaited the arrival of our culinary team, hoping they hadn't been poached by said chef and would show up for work. They did. We opened. We held our breath through the weekend, and by Sunday evening, we exhaled.


Over the next few months, I created new systems for ordering, menu changes, prep work and chain of command in the kitchen. We quickly realized that our culinary team, some of whom had been with us since we opened, was perfectly capable of leading us through service. In fact, they'd been doing it all along. I began to experience something unexpected: relief. At long last, I could dictate the menu we wanted in our own restaurant. One that certainly included garlic bread!


Surviving the occasional culinary mutiny is one thing. Remembering why we put ourselves through it is another. And sometimes that reminder comes from the most unexpected places. In our early days, a Deal Middle School student wrote a review of I'm Eddie Cano for a school paper. He spoke about being greeted at the door by Massimo, feeling a sense of community in our restaurant, and experiencing Italy through his meal. Without knowing our simple truth, he'd felt and identified the very thing we'd set out to create.


At the time, we still gathered the entire team for a pre-shift lineup and staff meal. We invited this young man and his parents to join us. He read his review aloud to the people who had made his experience possible. By my calculations, he's probably a junior in college by now. I no longer have his review, but I've never forgotten how he made us feel. Nor have I forgotten what it meant to have him sitting among us that afternoon.


We opened our doors hoping to become part of the neighborhood. Somewhere along the way, the neighborhood became part of us.

1 Comment


assisted living
4 days ago

Your description of families returning for milestones shows why a familiar table can carry so much meaning. I manage the website for Potomac Seniors Village in Potomac, Maryland. When arranging a celebration with an older relative, I would start by asking which tradition they want to preserve, then work out the practical details around that preference. It need not be a large event; the connection to the place may be the most important part.

Like
bottom of page